All Ages shows carry a weird stigma to me, especially when it comes to the world of hardcore. Although I do believe that hardcore is such an important thing that has helped raised me, I am a little glad that I didn't start going to shows until I was 18. Over the short couple of years that I have been around, I've begun to see the importance of all ages shows, but also the importance of doing them right and being safe for younger crowd.
The younger generations is a huge driving force into any subculture that you can think of. Naturally, they are filled with more energy and excitement for the movements than some of us that have been going to shows, supporting the bands or overall engaging with this community. I won't claim to be a veteran at all since I have only been going to shows since early 2022, but I have been listening to this style way prior to my first show. Regardless, I didn't really know how to act even at the age of 18, much less at shows. Quickly enough, I feel like I really got my footing in the scene about a year of going to shows consistently and even longer to get my footing with my own music. The unfortunate truth is this; we were all cringe at various points of our lives but especially more-so when we were younger, ignorant kids. I don't care how much of a cool guy or pretentious nerd you are; there's no way you've gone through life without having some embarrassing moments. However, this brings me back to my original point which is that the younger generation needs a place where they can let out their energy in a grand community, especially here in the United States. The United States has an issue of having a terribly low amount of third spaces with all of our childhood malls dying, parks limiting their workers and instilling curfews and even 'mom and pop' local bowling, arcades and other such activities struggling to keep the doors open especially after the pandemic accompanied by the rising costs of everything. Naturally with the death of these third places, the younger crowd will desperately find any sort of entertainment that they can grasp at and most likely, they'll find out about shows through friends or social media. This is where the All-Ages venues come into play and where keeping it safe (for both the minors and the venue) is absolutely crucial.
This is mostly an opinion based writeup and I am in no way, shape or form an expert on these topics but these are the things that I see and believe. I might be biased based upon my own personal life choices but absolutely NO selling of drugs or alcohol at an all-ages venue. I can already feel the groans from a couple readers, but a hardcore show is absolutely not the place where minors should be getting wasted at (if at all but let's be honest, most of us have done underaged drinking including myself). The fact that a minor has easy access to substances of all kind while being near the energy of a hardcore show is just a walking liability. Sure, the venue can try to mitigate that by making kids X up, refusing reentry, etc but there's still a very real probability that if they really wanted to, they could get access to it through friends or mischievous methods. I say the best option would be to make the said venue a sober space by either closing down the bar for the night or better yet, hosting the show at a location that doesn't even have the option of a bar but that is easier said than done. I don't believe that many venue owners are keen on the idea of shutting down their bars, especially if that's where they get a lot of their money from and a spot without a bar that is willing to host a hardcore show are very far and few between. On another note, all-ages shows aren't bad in nature but the shows that are booked must also be kept in check. This might be a hot take, but I'll be very honest; I do not think that kids should be at beatdown shows at all! It gets very difficult nowadays to determine whether a band is a beatdown band or not, but if you're booking a bill and you think it's going to be a scary turnout, make it 18+. That might not be as controversial as a take as it is in my head, but I still felt like putting it out there. It takes 2 minutes to search up beatdown live shows to understand why having a random 14-year-old who is new to scene is a BAD IDEA. I'm all for standard, run-of-the-mill hardcore being all ages because I feel like at least those bands bring a more respectful crowd because I'd feel more comfortable taking my kid to see Youth of Today versus Shattered Realm (I hope that many feel the same way too). That is just the unfortunate reality though, as I'd rather limit the amount of all ages shows than risk kids getting seriously fucked up which could lead to venues shutting down (AND it has!). Rest in peace to the Audobon church venue which, iirc, got shut down due to some angry parent threatening to sue! It's such things like these which is why all-ages shows are a very delicate craft that can easily lead to fucking over a LOT of people.
As a community, we have to protect ourselves with the youth included. We need to take into account the number of substances that the children will be exposed to, the audience members and the overall abrasive energy that hardcore provides. This community is such a great gateway into a better lifestyle where you can meet a lot of people that can be very supportive of you till the very end. I have met some great people, and our friendships have stood the cruel test of time. However, there are those unfortunate predators that lurk around that'll take any opportunity to prey on people, including children. It is not just the responsibility of promoters and bands, but also of the people within the crowd to protect ourselves, now more than ever. Abusive and predatory behaviors must not only be called out but taken into account and be treated very seriously. There is an unfortunate tendency that some have where they'll protect their abusive friend just because they don't believe that they would be capable of heinous acts, even if presented with a large amount of evidence. There'll always be a gray area in terms of allegations and callouts but if a certain individual has multiple allegations against them, chances are they're an asshole. People lie all the time, but most victims have nothing to gain from calling out evil behaviors, especially if they can be easily disproven. In my several years of being a part of different communities, I have yet to see ONE local instance where the allegations were actually proven to be false! I wouldn't want to take my kid to a show if I knew that there were good chances that outted child predators would be in the audience, with most just turning a blind eye. Now obviously that is an overly dramatic hypothetical, but you understand my point, right?